Solving
the Protein Controversy
For
vegetarians and meat eaters alike, the question
of protein is vital to good health. How much is ideal? What are the
best
sources? When is the best time of day to consume protein? Answering
these
questions could be the key to the vibrant health you have been looking
for.
If you read about nutrition or dieting at all, you are bound to notice
that there is a raging controversy about protein. Some writers
recommend
huge amounts of protein, even up to 200 grams/day!!! - a sure way to
overload yourself with toxins and eventually destroy your kidneys. At
the
other extreme are fruitarians claiming that you can get all the protein
you
need from raw fruit. I think the truth is somewhere in between.
While it is true that raw fruit does have enough protein to sustain
life, it does not supply enough to maintain cellular protein reserves
for
building and repair, or emergency energy supplies. Fruits supply mainly
carbohydrates, providing quick energy, but as a total diet they create
weak
tissue integrity and cannot build vibrant health.
Of all the information I have studied (and it has been quite a bit) I
would say that the Pro-Vita! Plan, recommending 22-30 grams/100lbs of
body
weight, offers the most sensible and well-documented approach to using
protein in your diet. Based on the work of master herbalist and
biochemist,
Dr. Stuart Wheelwright, it is explained in great detail by Jack Dr.
Jack
Tipps in his book "The Pro-Vita! Plan for Optimal Nutrition." This is a
must-read for vegans or vegetarians, and highly recommended for
everyone
else! It covers a wealth of information that I can't even begin to
cover
here.
While I like Ann Louise Gittleman's Fat Flush & Detox systems
for
their clarity of presentation, balance of nutrients, and focus on liver
support, I think her protein recommendations are about twice as high as
they should be. Eating her recommended eight ounces of protein a day
will
leave most people feeling bloated, constipated, and over-acidic, even
if
you follow her fiber recommendations.
Gitttleman also does not address the issue of the natural pH cycles of
the body, which govern protein metabolism. Nor does she take the
bio-availability of proteins into consideration. And for vegetarians
and
vegans, the only option she offers is blue green algae, which does not
offer enough variety, plus it gets very boring after awhile! So, for
the
protein portion of her diets, I would recommend following the Pro-Vita!
Plan.
The Pro-Vita! Plan is based on protein metabolism. The basic idea
behind the plan is that protein is most easily digested in the morning,
or
before 2 p. m., because this is when the body pH is at the optimum
level to
handle it:
"The point about timing the major meal is quite simple. Protein foods
are best introduced to the body early in the day, so they become
available
when we want to be active and productive. Carbohydrates and alkaline
foods
are best eaten in the meal preceding sleep, because they are more
sedative
in their effect. These foods also support the cleansing of the acidic
metabolic wastes during sleep." ~ Jack Tips, The Pro Vita Plan, p.174
Eating carbohydrates for breakfast works against the body's natural pH
cycle, making more work for the digestive system and eventually wearing
down the body. Combining protein with carbohydrates is even worse,
because
it interferes with digestion, causing mucus and cholesterol build up,
as
well as artery clogging and heart disease.
The Pro-Vita! Plan is designed to build strong protein metabolism and
strong adrenals, while avoiding blood sugar fluctuations, and providing
higher energy, more productivity, and positive emotions. The basic idea
is
to eat low-stress, or easily-digested proteins early in the day. Save
carbohydrates (starches and sugars) for after 2 p. m., and never
combine
proteins with carbohydrates.
Here's a list of easily-digested (low-stress) proteins you can choose
from:
* Vegan - Sesame tahini, tempe, tofu, soybean miso,
wild rice (cooked
without boiling), sprouted beans (cooked without boiling), sprouts
(especially sunflower), soaked seeds, dulse, young green coconut,
chlorella, blue green algae, beet leaf (a little goes a long way,
according
to the book), soaked nuts in moderation (best if made into nut milk),
raw
red potato juice
NOTE: Crock pots are great for recommended low-temperature cooking.
Mini-crock pots are ideal for one or two portions.
* Vegetarian - raw cheese and milk, yogurt (don't combine dairy with
meats), free range eggs (cooked below 200 degrees)
* Seafood - Scallops, shrimp (cooked in garlic or beer to remove
puricines), conch, octopus, squid, some ocean fish (Pacific salmon, Red
snapper, Marlin, Mahi Mahi, and a few others from less-polluted areas -
see
book pg. 141)
* Meat - Gelatin (Sorry meat lovers, but meat isn't a low-stress
protein. You can eat it once in awhile on this plan, combined with raw
vegetables (i.e. a salad), but it's not the optimal protein source.)
Here's a simple breakfast idea - pick one cooked protein (i.e. tofu, tempe, poached egg,
shrimp...) and one cooked non-starchy vegetable (i.e.
carrot, broccoli, artichoke, asparagus...), add a salad of mixed greens
and
sprouts, with a dash of flax oil, or extra virgin olive oil and lemon,
or
vinegar and toss. Easy!
Keep a supply of options available and you won't have any trouble
coming up with a delicious breakfast in about five minutes. The basics
I
like to keep on hand are:
* Organic seeds (sesame, shelled sunflower, pumpkin, flax, chia, pine
nuts...) These are always soaked overnight. I keep a jar of mixed seeds
in
my refrigerator and scoop out three or four tablespoons each night to
soak
in filtered water for the next morning's breakfast. (Flax and chia will
get
gelatinous, so if you don't like the texture, leave them out... but
they
are great for making dehydrated crackers!)
* A variety of sprouts (alfalfa, broccoli, sunflower, buckwheat...)
Available at natural food stores, or Trader Joes, or grow your own.
Count
as vegetables and as proteins!
* A variety of organic vegetables for cooking, or eating raw. Salad
mixes often contain several vegetables.
* Organic soy miso - for flavoring. Counts as protein and aids in
preventing radiation poisoning. (The salt helps create hydrochloric
acid
for digesting protein.)
* Sesame tahini (excellent source of calcium and protein)
* Fresh young Tahi coconuts (source of electrolytes, protein, and pure
water)
* Dulse flakes (salty flavor, high in minerals)
* Spirulina/blue green algae (concentrated source of protein and
chlorophyll)
Once you take care of your protein requirements in the first meal or
two of the day, you can have vegetarian pasta dishes, starchy
vegetables,
and breads in the late afternoon and evening. Or just have a fruit
salad
for dinner.
Just be sure to:
* avoid combining protein with carbohydrates (starches or sweets) -
interferes with digestion, causing mucus, cholesterol build up, artery
clogging, and heart disease.
* always include raw vegetables (for enzymes and minerals) with
protein or carb meals
* eat fruit by itself
* relax, have fun with it, and don't be afraid to cheat now and then
Once you get past the habit of eating carbs in the morning, I bet
you'll find that this can be a very satisfying and delicious way to
start
your day!
If you want to really enhance your protein metabolism for optimal
results, follow the 5 + 5 Meal Plan. Combine five easily-digested
proteins
(one cooked and four raw) with one cooked and four raw vegetables in at
least one meal early in the day. This way you are sure to get a
complete
balance of amino acids (the building blocks of protein), vitamins,
minerals, and enzymes. It may sound like it would take a lot of
preparation, but it can really be quite simple. You just have to stock
up
on a few basic items, and meal preparation will be a snap. Start with
simple salads or soups and expand from there. Recipes are included in
the
book.
The reason for combining one cooked with four raw foods in each group
is that some nutrients are released by cooking, while others are
destroyed
by cooking. Because certain amino acids are damaged at high heat, raw
protein sources will provide about twice the amount of necessary amino
acids (building blocks of protein) as cooked sources, so you can eat
half
as much protein by volume and still satisfy the needs of the body. This
in
turn relieves the burden on the liver and kidneys of processing an
overabundance of protein. Combining raw with cooked organic foods
supplies
all the necessary nutrients for good health in the most easily
assimilated
way. You'll never have to take supplements again if you make a habit of
eating this way!
Note to vegans and vegetarians:
Unless you have what is known as the intrinsic factor, you cannot
support long-term good health on a totally vegetarian diet. The
intrinsic
factor is most often found in Asians, East Indians, and people who did
not
eat meat for the first eight years of their lives.
You can test yourself to see if you have the intrinsic factor by
taking between 100 - 200 mg. of niacin (not niacin-amide) on an empty
stomach. If you don't have the intrinsic factor you will experience a
flushing of the skin. This means you need to eat a small amount of fish
once a week (as little as two cubic inches - i.e. one large shrimp) to
supply the intrinsic factor.
There are also homeopathic remedies that can assist digestion in favor
of a vegetarian diet. See a qualified homeopathic doctor for more
information.
Taking a sub-lingual vitamin B12 supplement is also mandatory if you
are a vegan.
(You
may also be interested in reading Jack Tips' other book -
Your
Liver, Your Lifeline.
The Pro-Vita Plan
|